Industries requiring process heat rejection often use field-erected cooling towers to keep pace with their heat load. Cooling towers have large fans and powerful motors, presenting a host of challenges, including excessive sound, vibration and expense. Gearboxes are employed to address these challenges.
Gearboxes Play a Key Role to Multiply Torque
Gearboxes are used as speed reducers to slow the rotational speed from the incoming motor to the outgoing fan of a cooling tower. Companies operating high-capacity production plants, such as those in the chemical process and power industries, require cooling towers with large amounts of heat rejection capacity.
Without gearbox technology, cooling tower motors would be massive to directly handle the torque required by the fan. Something so large and heavy would be too expensive and impractical. Instead, the speed reduction from the gearbox acts as a torque multiplier, keeping the motor a reasonable size and the overall mechanical system more cost-effective.
As fan diameters increase, the fan speed must decrease to maintain acceptable sound and vibration levels.
The speed reduction from gearboxes also optimizes the performance of the cooling tower fan. As fan diameters increase, the fan speed must decrease to maintain acceptable sound and vibration levels, as well as to ensure the structural integrity of the fan itself. Improper gearbox sizing as it relates to the motor and fan can result in excessive vibration, loud operation and structural damage to the tower.
In large cooling tower applications, the fan typically operates at a speed between 100-200 rpm. The most common motor speed is 1800 rpm, requiring the average gearbox to reduce motor speed by approximately 9-18 times to achieve the desired fan speed. The exact combination of this gearbox ratio, fan blade design and fan pitch contributes to the specific performance and energy efficiency of the cooling tower in a given application.
Gearboxes are used as speed reducers to slow the rotational speed from the incoming motor to the outgoing fan of a cooling tower.
Cooling Tower Customers Seek Solutions to Common Gearbox Problems
Cooling tower operators and maintenance engineers cite several common pain points associated with gearbox operation and service:
Issue 1: High operating temperatures, contributing to shorter operating cycles, premature gearbox failure and unplanned downtime.
Issue 2: Excessive sound and vibration levels, resulting in municipal noise violations, employee safety issues, equipment fatigue and premature failure.
Issue 3: Extreme temperature and humidity conditions within the cooling tower, quickly degrading mechanical systems, affecting sound level and life of gear sets.
Issue 4: Premature bearing failure and excessive wearing of the pinion shaft.
Issue 5: Few gearbox options and choices to support either scheduled or unscheduled maintenance and replacement.
Advancements in Gearbox Design Address User Needs
Continuous product research and development activities have led to several recent design innovations and product enhancements. SPX Cooling Technologies’ engineers identified the following solutions to address the five gearbox operational issues most often cited by plant managers and maintenance engineers:
Solution #1: To address high operating temperatures, select a gear drive with integral “cooling fins” designed into the housing. In lieu of a smooth casting, the cooling fins increase surface area, allowing better heat rejection as air is pulled over the gearbox by the cooling tower fan. For example, Marley Geareducer® brand gearboxes include cooling fins, increasing the surface area by 25-47 percent compared to other cooling tower gear drives. Geareducers also incorporate large internal oil ports to keep oil well-circulated and contribute to overall cooler operating temperatures. The results: Oil life is extended, fewer oil changes are required, and gears and bearings are properly lubricated to maximize performance and service life.
To address high operating temperatures, select a gear drive with integral “cooling fins” designed into the housing.
Solution #2: To dampen excessive sound and vibration levels associated with gearboxes, select for robust metal castings. Choose a gearbox engineered to minimize the case deflection associated with the immense torque and thrust loads specific to cooling tower duty. For example, Marley Geareducers feature up to 40 percent thicker castings and are designed and built expressly for cooling tower service. The results: Quieter, safer working conditions, less metal fatigue and longer service life.
Solution #3: To counteract the extreme temperature and humidity conditions cooling tower gear drives are subjected to, steel shims at case connection points offer advantages. Steel shims, in lieu of plastic versions, are incorporated into all Marley Geareducer designs. Plastic shims exposed to temperature and humidity conditions within the tower can creep over time, causing changes in tolerance that affect the sound and life of the gear sets. The results: Steel shims maintain proper gear settings and control gear sound under extreme operating conditions.
Solution #4: To guard against premature bearing failure and excessive wearing of the pinion shaft, use heavy-duty double row interstage bearings. Bearing life of 100,000 hours is routinely achievable. A premium-grade isolator-type bearing oil seal with fixed stator sealing surface to prevent shaft wear is also recommended in lieu of a lip type seal that wears against the pinion shaft. To illustrate, Marley Geareducers incorporate an Inpro/Seal* bearing isolator which extends seal life without the downside of excess wearing of the shaft. The results: The use of heavy-duty double row bearings and oil seals can protect gearboxes from premature wear and extend service life.
Solution #5: To expand gearbox repair or replacement options and choices for either scheduled or unscheduled maintenance, choose a reliable supplier with specific knowledge of gear drives and an extensive inventory of cooling tower componentry. For example, SPX Cooling Technologies offers a dedicated in-house gearbox evaluation team, experienced in the inspection, repair and rebuilding of both Marley and Amarillo brand gearboxes. Gearbox repairs are completed at the SPX manufacturing plant, rather than contracted to job shops. To speed completion, avoid delays and additional costs, transportation to and from the plant is included.
A New Option to Simplify the Replacement Process
A recent SPX engineering innovation has been the expansion of the Marley Geareducer line. The new M Series Geareducer, debuted in early 2017, simplifies replacement of gearboxes in field-erected towers that do not currently employ a Marley Geareducer. The M Series is a direct “drop-in” replacement for Amarillo brand gearboxes, with a matching footprint that greatly simplifies gearbox change-out procedures.
A viable new alternative for gearbox replacements is important to plant operators. The M Series eliminates time-consuming conversion parts, such as fan hubs, driveshafts and adapter plates, as well as the added material costs and field labor time they require. The reduced time and effort onsite means a safer installation and less overall downtime for the tower, and a more reliable and affordable installation for the plant.
The M Series combines the proven longevity and performance of robust housings and bearings with modern seal enhancements and built-in vibration transducer mounting. It can be expected to provide reliable service for 12 to 15 years, with proper maintenance, before major repairs or rebuilding is a factor. It doesn’t require any external pumps, filters or coolers to run properly, sparing customers extra unexpected costs and other add-on components that could become problematic. The M Series Geareducer provides the solutions customers want from an industrial grade cooling tower gearbox.
Reliable Gearboxes Alleviate “Service Anxiety”
Plant operators and maintenance engineers must effectively manage a variety of cooling tower service issues, whether scheduled or unplanned. Finding common-sense, long-term solutions to the most common pain-points not only simplifies routine maintenance and repair operations, but goes a long way to alleviate service anxiety. Reliable gearboxes and dependable suppliers provide a sense of security that maintenance and service issues can be managed methodically instead of in crisis mode.
About the Author:
Jerome Jennings is a global product manager for field-erected components at SPX Cooling Technologies, based in Overland Park, Kansas. For more information visit www.spxcooling.com.
To read similar Cooling Tower Technology articles visit www.coolingbestpractices.com/technology/cooling-towers.
*Inpro/Seal® is a registered trademark of Waukesha Bearings Corporation.